Dina Kamal
ECONOMIC SHOCKS AND TAX MORALE
Tax revenues constitute a fundamental way for countries to generate public revenues that make it possible to finance investments in human capital, infrastructure, and the provision of services for citizens and businesses in order to support ongoing economic development (Burgess & Stern, 1993). It is therefore important to understand the factors that may influence citizens’ decisions to evade, or not evade, paying taxes, among other levers that governments should consider to increase tax compliance. This thesis aimed to consider various economic and/or political shocks, using the transition of communist regimes and the Great Recession as examples, and to explore how related elements may have had an effect on, or an association with, citizens’ tax morale, i.e., willingness to pay taxes, as a proxy for tax compliance. Despite the extended tax evasion literature that has assessed different factors that influence tax morale in various settings, as covered in the literature review section, there is limited literature that considers the context of economic shocks, like recessions, or significant changes in political and economic regimes, as in the case of transitioning from Communism. In this thesis I viewed these settings as introducing unique factors that influence tax morale and explored the severity of the economic impacts and how governments responded to these economic shocks. Understanding these factors is important as governments typically experience a greater need to increase their revenue after recessions or as part of an economic transformation.
The thesis is comprised of six chapters. Chapter 1 presents the introduction, including the motivation and objective of the thesis, as well as a review of tax morale literature and a statement of the methodological approach that unifies the four empirical studies. Chapter 2 considers the effect on tax morale of being a citizen of a country with a communist heritage. The empirical analysis examines 85 countries around the world, 28 of which have a communist heritage (i.e., are ex-communist), based on a conceptual framework informed by existing literature on tax morale and the psychology of living in an ex-communist country. The results of the analysis show that living in a country with a communist past has a negative association with tax morale. This effect seems to be persistent many years after these countries transitioned out of Communism. The related hypothesis argued that individuals from countries with a history of Communism carry a psychological baggage that is in many ways unique from those living in countries that do not share this heritage. Chapter 3 considers the role of the Great Recession of 2007–2009 as an economic shock broadly across countries to assess the potential association between citizens’ tax morale and their governments’ roles, if any, in triggering the recession, the severity of the economic impact, and the nature of the governments’ responses. I did this by building a rich secondary data set that included responses from the World Values Survey (WVS), among other sources, and by applying qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) to conduct a cross-country comparison of 14 countries. The analysis points to an association of positive change in average tax morale per country and change in the ruling party when the trigger of the recession is considered internal. Meanwhile, positive change in tax morale is associated with countries that have no change in ruling party when the trigger of the recession is considered to be due to external factors. Economic conditions appear only as a peripheral contributing condition in the identified configurations, while smaller fiscal stimulus packages — contrary to expectations — form part of the configurations associated with a positive change in tax morale. Chapter 4 considers the Great Recession of 2007–2009 in the United States to assess the potential association between U.S. citizens’ tax morale and the severity of the economic impact and how the U.S. government responded to this financial crisis. I did this by building a rich secondary data set across 29 states from various U.S. government sources and the WVS as input for empirical analysis. The empirical analysis of tax morale across 29 states implies that state-level change in unemployment rates, GDP growth, and foreclosures does not seem to influence individual tax morale. Furthermore, the total size of stimulus packages in each state does not seem to have a statistically significant association with tax morale, when controlling for the change in the individual states’ tax policies. Direct stimulus, i.e., household transfers, shows a small negative association with tax morale, although this association is only marginally significant once inference accounts for the small number of state clusters. Chapter 5 considers the effect of the intensity of protests across the various governorates in Egypt during the Arab Spring on Egyptians’ tax morale and on their embrace of democracy. I measured protest intensity by the per capita casualties (killings and injuries) per governorate during the Arab Spring. The analysis in this section leverages the WVS, specifically Wave 5, which took place before the Arab Spring (2005–2009), and Wave 6, which took place after the Arab Spring (2010–2014). The empirical analysis shows that the occurrence of the Arab Spring has a negative association with tax morale—a result that is robust to inference accounting for the small number of governorates—while the intensity of the protests per governorate seems to have a positive association with tax morale, although this latter association is not robust to the same test and should be read as suggestive. It also shows that embracing democracy is positively, though not statistically significantly, associated with tax morale. Introducing the embrace of democracy dilutes the effect of protest intensity. There is also an empirical positive association between protest intensity per governorate and the increase in the embrace of democracy by Egyptian citizens. Finally, Chapter 6 concludes the thesis by summarizing the study’s key findings, policy implications, limitations, and avenues for further research.
| Publicatiedatum | 7 december 2026 |
| Universiteit | Universiteit Maastricht |
| Auteur | Dina Kamal |
| ISBN nummer | 978-94-6534-743-1 |