Jamleck Osiemo Oroko
Technology Adoption and Economic Transformation in Kenya
Agricultural innovations and technologies designed to enhance productivity and strengthen risk management in small-scale agriculture are pivotal for the economic transformation of low-income countries. Yet, for decades, adoption of such innovations has remained puzzlingly low despite their availability in most cases. There is no single binding constraint to the adoption of productivity-enhancing technologies and risk management strategies by small-scale farmers. Understanding this persistent “adoption puzzle” therefore requires a multidimensional approach.
This thesis focuses on the roles of agricultural risk, information, and informal markets in explaining the adoption puzzle. It conceptualizes technology adoption as a process that begins with farmers’ perceptions of the risks they face, followed by matching available technologies to those risks, and ultimately selecting the technologies that address their most salient risks. However, the adoption story is not this trivial. Behavioral biases influence how farmers perceive risks and evaluate technologies even when opportunities for learning are available. Moreover, dynamics in informal markets, particularly information asymmetries around unobservable quality for both productivity-enhancing inputs and outputs, further complicate the process. Within this framework, the thesis addresses three key questions: i) Which risks and risk attributes are most important to farmers, and do risk perceptions differ between men and women? ii) How do farmers value technologies, and do these valuations reflect underlying preferences and risk perceptions? iii) Can addressing information frictions at both production and market levels unlock technology uptake?
The analysis of farmers’ risk perceptions revealed that multiple risks are salient, extending beyond production to include market, financial, and personal risks. The thesis critiques the prevailing bias toward production-related risks and advocates for innovations and technologies that address this broader risk spectrum through approaches such as risk layering and innovative bundling. It also finds that men and women perceive risks differently. Since risk perceptions strongly influence technology adoption, gender-responsive innovations must go beyond addressing the “symptoms” of inequality such as limited access to land, credit, and information to also account for the underlying psychological and structural factors that shape these disparities.
In exploring how farmers value technologies, the thesis focuses on improved forage varieties and index insurance. Willingness to pay (WTP) for improved varieties, like most crops, was below market prices but slightly higher for varieties with which farmers had prior experience. WTP did not differ significantly across varieties, likely because farmers did not pay attention to the subtle, unique differences each variety offered. This underscores the importance of providing farmers opportunities to experiment with new technologies so they can fully appreciate the unique “improvements”.
Regarding index insurance, farmers expressed a strong preference for a multiple-peril product that covers major losses from multiple risks, rather than conventional single-peril products that insure against only one type of risk. The thesis shows that choice architecture influences technology decisions: farmers may exhibit “preference reversals” when introduced to alternative technologies. Consequently, relying solely on ex-ante WTP elicitations to inform pricing and subsidy policies risks overlooking important behavioral dynamics, oversights that may have significant implications for adoption.
Because learning takes time and outcomes are influenced by external factors such as weather, extension approaches that foster experiential learning and shorten the feedback loop between experimentation and results are crucial. This thesis tested game-based learning as an alternative to conventional narrative-based extension and found it significantly more effective in helping farmers understand index insurance. Farmers exposed to high basis risk in the experimental setting showed lower demand for insurance, suggesting that they better grasped the product’s limitations compared to those who only received information about basis risk.
The thesis further examines the potential of using observable quality attributes as proxies for unobservable ones, focusing on aflatoxin contamination in maize in addressing incomplete information on quality in informal markets. Providing market actors with information on the link between kernel integrity and aflatoxin contamination led to modest improvements in maize quality in informal markets. Sales volumes of high-quality maize increased, although prices remained unchanged, and the effects faded within three months. This fade-out highlights the need for sustained information campaigns and complementary dissemination channels, such as mass media, to reinforce learning and behavioral change.
In conclusion, understanding farmers’ risk perceptions is a crucial step toward explaining farmers’ heterogeneity in technology adoption. While information plays a central role in adoption, the mode of delivery matters greatly: farmers learn best through experiential modalities that reduce the gap between experimentation and outcome realization. Finally, dynamics within informal grain markets in low-income countries may hinder the development of market-based incentives for quality improvement even when actors have information on quality. More research is therefore needed to identify sustainable market mechanisms that can drive on-farm adoption of quality-enhancing technologies.
| Publicatiedatum | 7 oktober 2026 |
| Universiteit | Wageningen University |
| Auteur | Jamleck Osiemo Oroko |
| ISBN nummer | 978-94-6534-688-5 |
| DOI nummer | 10.18174/681062 |