Dobrina Poirier
Meaningful E-Participation Outcomes Through the Interplay of Supply and Demand-Side Drivers
Summary
This dissertation addresses a key gap in the e-participation literature, which has often examined adoption through fragmented supply-side (government and institutions) or demand-side (citizens and users) perspectives. This fragmentation is counter to the very essence of participation which is intended as a deliberative process that brings citizens and government together to co-create policy and improve service delivery efficiency. The study addresses two important gaps in the e-participation literature. First, limited attention has been paid to how supply and demand-side drivers interact in practice to influence adoption and meaningful outcomes of e-participation initiatives. Second, much of the literature implicitly assumes that adoption naturally produces meaningful outcomes, despite limited empirical evidence to that effect (Fung, 2015).
These gaps shaped the analytical direction of the dissertation and motivated the development of a consolidated theoretical framework focused on the interplay between drivers and the conditions under which participation becomes meaningful.
The dissertation employs a mixed-methods research design. The quantitative phase, using longitudinal panel data from European regions (2010–2022), explores the influence of supply and demand-side drivers on e-participation adoption. The qualitative phase draws on case studies of the Citizens’ Guide to the Budget and Irembo.Gov in Rwanda to examine how the interaction between supply and demand-side drivers shapes e-participation outcomes. Rwanda was purposefully selected as an extreme case (Patton, 2015), as it exhibits contradictory conditions: strong supply-side e-government readiness, contrasted with weak demand conditions, within hierarchical governance traditions.
The study makes four key contributions. First, it establishes the centrality of demand-side drivers, by showing that they are at least as important as supply-side drivers in shaping e-participation adoption and outcomes. Second, it conceptualizes e-participation as the mediated interplay of supply and demand-side drivers, where outcomes are not determined by the drivers themselves, but by how their interaction is mediated, governed, and institutionalized. Third, it demonstrates that adoption does not necessarily translate into meaningful outcomes and introduces a distinction between instrumental and transformative outcomes. Finally, the insights culminate in the presentation of a Revised E-participation Framework for Meaningful Outcomes, that views participation as a relational governance process shaped by a number of pre-conditions (institutional willingness and power dynamics) and the mediation quality of the supply-demand side interface.
The dissertation is organized into seven chapters. Chapter 1 introduces the research problem, objectives and questions. Chapter 2 reviews the e-participation literature, examines relevant theoretical perspectives and develops the study’s initial conceptual framework. Chapter 3 presents the quantitative analysis which explores the variations in e-participation adoption and its drivers across European countries and regions. Chapter 4 outlines the study’s qualitative research design, drawing on an exploratory multiple-case study methodology in an extreme setting. Chapter 5 examines the two Rwandan cases in detail: the Citizens’ Guide to the Budget and Irembo.Gov. Chapter 6 brings together the quantitative and qualitative findings, discussing how supply and demand-side drivers interact within different institutional and contextual settings; and introduces the Revised E-Participation Framework for Meaningful Outcomes. Finally, Chapter 7 synthesizes the findings, discusses their implications for theory and practice, and offers conclusions and recommendations for policymakers and future research.
| Publicatiedatum | 20 oktober 2026 |
| Universiteit | Universiteit Maastricht |
| Auteur | Dobrina Poirier |
| ISBN nummer | 978-94-6534-662-5 |