Annemiek Hermans

Charged Encounters

Offshore wind farms (OWFs) and associated cables do not form hard barriers for the presence or movement of benthic elasmobranchs. The hypothesis of broad habitat avoidance can thus be rejected, while room remains for more subtle behavioral changes.

The thesis then focuses on controlled laboratory experiments investigating life-stage specific behavioral changes under realistic exposure scenarios. Chapter 4 examines the embryonic development of the thornback ray (Raja clavata) under chronic exposure to AC electromagnetic fields (EMF). No effects were found on hatching success, weight at hatching, or development duration, but a strong increase in embryo activity (150%) was observed, which could indicate increased energy costs and predation risk. In the hatched animals, significant but limited biometric differences (5–11%) were identified.

Chapter 5 follows these individuals into the juvenile stage and compares them with the small-spotted catshark (Scyliorhinus canicula). Juveniles exposed during embryonic development showed no differences in stress or swimming behavior compared to the control group, and all individuals appeared to be in good health. These results indicate that early exposure did not lead to clear limitations in the juvenile stage for both species. However, a knowledge gap remains regarding effects on foraging, navigation, and interactions with conspecifics, emphasizing that subtle behavioral changes may not persist in subsequent life stages.

Chapter 6 investigates the behavioral responses of adult small-spotted catsharks exposed to spatial gradients of field-relevant EMFs, simulating the experience of crossing a subsea power cable (SPC). Each individual served as its own control, and both AC and DC exposures were part of the trial. No evidence was found for stress behavior, attraction, avoidance, or changes in space use. However, under DC exposure, the sharks reduced their activity by approximately 25 percentage points, indicating a subtle but statistically significant change in activity patterns. These results suggest that SPCs do not form behavioral barriers, but DC fields in particular can influence movement dynamics.

In Chapter 7, the same experimental setup as in Chapter 6 was performed with the thornback ray (Raja clavata), allowing for a direct interspecific comparison. As with the sharks, the rays showed no attraction or avoidance, no clear signs of stress, and no changes in space use. However, Hidden Markov Modeling (HMM) showed small but statistically significant sex-specific responses: females were less (~15% pt.) inactive and showed more transition behavior under AC exposure, while males were more inactive (~14% pt.) under both AC and DC conditions compared to control trials. These findings show that even when responses are subtle, behavioral effects can differ between species and sexes.

Chapter 8 examines whether EMF affects the habitat use of juvenile small-spotted catsharks in a preference setup with quadrants offering a combination of mussel-covered versus bare substrate with and without EMF exposure. No differences in substrate choice or space use were found, but HMM analysis showed a significant but subtle increase in inactivity (5-6% pt.) in the quadrant with both mussels and EMF exposure. This experiment provides additional evidence that EMF likely does not lead to habitat avoidance on a small spatial scale.

Chapter 9 integrates these empirical findings within the Ecological Risk Assessment (ERA) framework. It confirms that EMF exposure levels at sea are generally lower than those used in many experimental studies but show high temporal variability. It emphasizes that both spatial extent and exposure probability are expected to increase with the further development of offshore wind energy. Behavioral effects, where present, are subtle and dependent on life stage, species, and sex. The main risk lies in the chronic, long-term nature of EMF as a stressor present over decades and large spatial scales.

Given the heterogeneity in responses, Chapter 9 introduces a Relative Vulnerability Assessment (RVA) based on life history traits to identify which ray and shark species are most vulnerable. This framework shows that oviparous, benthic, and resident species, such as large skates, form a higher risk group for embryonic development and local residency, whereas migratory shark species are primarily at risk during migration.

Lees verder
Publicatiedatum 28 augustus 2026
Universiteit Wageningen University
Auteur Annemiek Hermans

Bekijk ook deze projecten

Eris van Twist

Eris van Twist

Wageningen University Lees meer
Duco Steenbeek

Duco Steenbeek

Wageningen University Lees meer
Sanne Van Rooij

Sanne Van Rooij

Wageningen University Lees meer